malepatternboldness2

  • Subscribe to our RSS feed.
  • Twitter
  • StumbleUpon
  • Reddit
  • Facebook
  • Digg

Wednesday, January 26, 2011

How should a man's shirt fit? Peter's 20-shirt challenge!

Posted on 7:42 AM by dvdsvdsdv

Quick -- name those celebrity lats!

Friends, with less than one week before our Men's Shirt Sew-Along formally begins, I've been doing a lot of thinking and re-thinking about shirts.  We already have more than 100 Sew-Along participants, with numbers climbing daily, many using the Colette Negroni pattern and many using shirt patterns of their own choosing.  The shirt button numbers alone are staggering.

The construction details we're going to be addressing are relatively straightforward: flat-felled seams, rolled hems, sleeve plackets, collar stand and collar, etc.  The fabric you'll be working with is of your own choosing, and I can see from our Flickr group that they range from traditional stripe to Sixties acid trip.

Yesterday I took some time to closely investigate my own shirt collection, a mix of ready-to-wear shirts I've accumulated over the years, and my own creations crafted from vintage shirt patterns.

I also spent a few hours re-reading David Page Coffin's take on fitting a shirt and self-drafting a pattern from his classic book, Shirtmaking, which I know many of you are familiar with.





I want accurate fitting to be a focus of our Sew-Along and I think you do too.  I put on my thinking cap and have decided to invite a professional into our Sew-Along project!  Starting on the very first day of our Sew-Along I will be working privately with -- I can't mention his name yet, but you know it.  And what I learn I will be sharing with you here and in our Flickr group as we work on fitting our muslins and our final shirts.  You can get by with pinked seam allowances and bargain basement fabric, but if the shirt doesn't fit it's going to be obvious to everyone.

Fit has to be a sewist's biggest challenge.  It's also one that I have managed to avoid on my upper half, having convinced myself that I can wear a shirt made straight from a commercial pattern.  The truth is that I can get away with wearing a shirt made straight from a pattern.  The fit, however, is never ideal.

I've examined and recorded the fit of twenty shirts and I can tell you with confidence that none fits perfectly.  Some are closer than others of course, but there's work to do.

Most are decent, especially in front, where I have fewer fit issues.



 

Others, well....  off to the thrift store they go!



If you have the time and the inclination to pore through more than 100 pics of me in 20 different shirts, you can see them all here.   Strong coffee and a comfortable chair are recommended.

I kid you not when I say that before I started sewing, I gave the fit of this Brooks Brothers's shirt nary a second thought.  It was just the way things were.



Things have gotten better now that I make my own shirts, but there is tweaking to be done and I am ready to tweak.



Friends, we are going to do this together and we will have expert help.  Life is too short to stumble in semi-darkness.

Sew-Alongers and Sew-Along fence sitters, your assignment this week is to take a close look at the fit of either your own men's shirt (if you're male), or the shirt of the person you'll be sewing for (if you're female), preferably on the person himself.  Everybody else, do what makes sense.  With regards to fit, what works for you (and him) and what doesn't?  What looks too loose, what looks too tight?

If you can, upload a pic or two to the Flickr group page, so we can see what the perceived problems are.  We are shame-free here at MPB, rest assured.

And now, I've much to do -- including contending once again with this.



Will it never end?

Have a great day everybody.  How are those men's shirt fitting?  What are the challenges?  Share!
Email ThisBlogThis!Share to XShare to FacebookShare to Pinterest
Posted in Men's Shirt Sew-Along, mens shirt | No comments
Newer Post Older Post Home

0 comments:

Post a Comment

Subscribe to: Post Comments (Atom)

Popular Posts

  • Men's Shirt Sew-Along 17 -- Penultimate Post and Negroni 3 REVEAL!
    Loyal Sew-Alongers, Sew-Alongettes, and others, it's nearly time to say good-bye to our first-ever MPB Men's Shirt Sew-Along. The pa...
  • Requisite Halloween Post
    I don't think it's too early, do you? I recognize Halloween is a subject of relevance only to Americans (or so I believe); my apol...
  • The Last Toggle Post
    Dear readers, a million thanks for yesterday's comments.  I think we're all going to enjoy wearing this coat and don't think I...
  • MPB Men's Boxers Sew-Along 3 -- Let's Start Sewing!
    Good morning, Sew-Alongers and others eager to learn how to make boxers.  Today we are going to start sewing!  Yesterday I neglected to ment...
  • Behold the Refinished Featherweight Table!
    Friends, I simply couldn't wait till 2012 to show you my refinished Singer Featherweight table, which I fished out of the trash only one...
  • Shirt collar-palooza and the 1939 men's shirt
    Good morning, shirt mavens and others!  Here at Male Pattern Boldness , we're busy.  So busy in fact that my staff is demanding time-and...
  • The Wacky World of Color Forecasting
    Before I get started, why does current fashion illustration make women look like Bratz dolls?  I don't like it one bit. Moving right alo...
  • Can you see my butt crack?
    Readers, today I'm going to challenge your sense of decorum and tolerance.  The easily offended might want to come back tomorrow. Oh wis...
  • Doing Alterations for Others - Yea or Nay?
    Like many home sewers, I'm not into altering other people's clothes.  Heck, I don't even like to alter my own!  (Though, ironica...
  • Happiness is a Clean Sewing Table
    This may not look like anything to brag about to you, neat readers, but for me this is as good as it gets.  I can actually see the table und...

Categories

  • 20s glamour
  • 30s glamour
  • 40s glamour
  • 50s glamour
  • 60s glamour
  • 70s
  • age and aging
  • beauty
  • body art
  • books
  • button loops
  • Cathy
  • clothing and culture
  • completed projects
  • contests
  • crinoline
  • Daily Ditch (The)
  • decluttering
  • dime store psychology
  • dogs
  • dolls
  • Doris Day
  • fabric
  • fashion show
  • faux fur
  • flea market
  • Ginger Rogers
  • Guy week
  • Hats
  • interfacing
  • ironing
  • Jeans Sew-Along
  • Kenmore 158.1040
  • makeovers
  • Men's Boxers Sew-Along
  • men's fit issues
  • Men's Shirt Sew-Along
  • mens bathing suit
  • mens fashion
  • mens grooming
  • mens jeans
  • mens pajamas
  • mens pants
  • mens patterns
  • mens shirt
  • mens suit
  • mens toggle coat
  • mens underwear
  • mens western jacket
  • modeling
  • mothers
  • movies
  • MPB Day
  • my life
  • pattern drafting
  • patterns
  • Peter on video
  • Pfaff 30
  • project planning
  • sergers
  • sewing and culture
  • sewing basics
  • sewing machines
  • Shoes
  • shopping
  • singer 15-90
  • Singer 15-91
  • Singer 201
  • Singer 66
  • Singer 99K
  • Singer Featherweight
  • Singer treadle
  • topstitching
  • video
  • women I love
  • works in progress
  • YEA or NAY?

Blog Archive

  • ►  2012 (35)
    • ►  February (16)
    • ►  January (19)
  • ▼  2011 (313)
    • ►  December (24)
    • ►  November (25)
    • ►  October (20)
    • ►  September (29)
    • ►  August (21)
    • ►  July (24)
    • ►  June (22)
    • ►  May (30)
    • ►  April (28)
    • ►  March (31)
    • ►  February (28)
    • ▼  January (31)
      • Yellow Tracing Paper, Bill Cunningham et al.
      • Last Sunday before Sew-Along stream of consciousness
      • Sexy Valentine's Day Sewing or "Get a Room!"
      • Ouch! + Sewing on Edge
      • Further dealings with fit + YOUR favorite fit reso...
      • How should a man's shirt fit? Peter's 20-shirt ch...
      • Giveaway winners and SO MUCH MORE!
      • Peter models the McCall's 1954 Men's Sport Shirt!
      • MPB Birthday Extravaganza + Vogue Pattern GIVEAWAYS!
      • The RTW Western Shirt -- a close inspection
      • MPB SNOW DAY SPECIAL --100% men's shirt free!
      • 12 SEW-ALONG TIPS for 12 WAITING-FOR-SEW-ALONG days!
      • Men's custom-made shirt inspection!
      • Inspecting the Thomas Pink shirt
      • Peter models the Dubarry 1939 men's shirt!
      • I (collar) Stand Corrected or "Dubarry 1939 men's ...
      • Elusive interfacing consensus + GAP shirt inspection!
      • Pre-Shrinking Interfacing or "D'OH!"
      • Shirt collar-palooza and the 1939 men's shirt
      • Needles and Thread and a Sew-Along Flickr Group!
      • Men's Shirt Sew-Along -- Your questions answered!
      • The 14 shirtmaking tools you won't want to live wi...
      • Sunday Fun + Men's Shirt Pattern GIVEAWAY!
      • Where can I buy good cotton shirting?
      • MPB Men's Shirt Sew-Along!
      • The Wacky World of Men's Shirt Patterns
      • Peter models the men's plaid flannel shirt
      • Men's Flannel Shirt -- UNEDITED insomnia edition
      • ...and awaaay we go! The men's flannel shirt project
      • Where do we go from here?
      • Peter speaks! The Pfaff 30 VIDEO
  • ►  2010 (152)
    • ►  December (30)
    • ►  November (27)
    • ►  October (31)
    • ►  September (30)
    • ►  August (23)
    • ►  July (11)
Powered by Blogger.

About Me

dvdsvdsdv
View my complete profile